The Wolverine: Covering University of Michigan Football and Sports
Issue link: https://comanpub.uberflip.com/i/1547620
20 THE WOLVERINE ❱ DECEMBER 2026 just shows the team had success. You don't win that award without team suc- cess, and all the receivers making the plays, and the O-line blocking. So I ap- preciate it from them." If they shared in the limelight at the end of October, they certainly shared in the struggles that followed. Carr kept his presentation calm and measured follow- ing the devastating loss to the Spartans but made it clear both he and the team were frustrated at the lack of offensive efficiency. "At the end of the day, we're just not executing at a high enough level," Carr offered. "That's kind of been all season long. We continue to say that. We've got three games left, and we've got to get to the bottom of it, because I know offen- sively and probably the defense is just sick of it. That's how we feel. "They were running what we thought they would run — maybe a little bit more man coverage. We had a few injuries up front, had some new guys come in that hadn't played a lot this year. But I thought protection was good all day. Sometimes, it's just maybe holding onto the ball too long and guys getting in the backfield. Protection was solid all day." The last statement seemed more gra- ciousness than reality. Either way, it was a gut punch, literally and figuratively. Nobody needed to tell the son of a former Michigan quarterback and the grandson of former U-M head coach Lloyd Carr and also grandson of former Michigan All-American Tom Curtis what a home loss to Michigan State means. "This is a game that is circled on our schedule, from the start of the season," Carr said. "You want to win every game, but especially this one and the rivalry games. It definitely stings a little bit." Whittingham's postgame comments represented a complete 180 from the week before — just like what he wit- nessed on the field. "There's nothing productive about this game — zero," he said. "It's not one step back. It's three steps back. We couldn't run the ball. Couldn't throw the ball worth a darn. Turned it over four times. Couldn't make first downs. Couldn't make any third-down conver- sions — I think we were 2 of 10. Got the quarterback sacked 5 times. "Really, I can't come up with one posi- tive, offensively, in this game." As for the freshman, Whittingham didn't try to run cover, outside of stress- ing that he, as head coach, is responsible for everything on the field. "That was a game where we didn't play nearly as good as we hoped to up front, really in any capacity," Whittingham said. "We didn't run the ball well enough. We didn't protect the quarterback. We had 5 sacks. "As good as Tommy played two weeks ago, it was a big drop-off in this game with his efficiency. He'll be the first one to tell you that. He missed quite a few throws that were makeable throws and completions that should have been had." Beck himself absorbed the biggest sack, getting relieved of his duties in the 24 hours after the game. Nobody knew what that portended for the quarterback situation, but Carr figures to go on do- ing what he's done from the beginning — prepare like he's the starter, no matter what. REMAINING LOCKED IN Such an approach certainly served Carr well when Michigan coaches asked him to take over in the middle of the Penn State game. It will continue to do so, whoever stands at the helm for the remaining U-M contests. "Tommy is a complete football junkie," Whittingham said. "He's a student of the game. We've talked about how he studies film and how his preparation is outstanding. We don't need to hold back much, but we can certainly add a little bit to it. We're continuing to figure out what's his wheelhouse and where his strengths are … we'll just continue to build on that." Carr's dedication and all-business approach to the game didn't begin at the start of the season. It didn't ramp up 100-fold when he switched his ver- bal commitment from Miami (Ohio) to Michigan. The brother of Notre Dame quarterback C.J. Carr demonstrated those same traits at Saline High School, according to his coach there, Kyle Short. Short told The Wolverine after Tommy Carr committed to Michigan how the prep QB reacted to the biggest audible of his senior season. Short's wife went into labor prior to a Saline versus Dexter showdown, and the coach needed to let his quarterback know the staff would be Short-handed that night. "I called Tommy out of fifth hour, which is about 2 p.m.," Short recalled. "I said, 'Hey Tommy, I'm not going to be able to coach today. I've got to go to the hospital. My wife is in labor.' He looks at me like, what? I said, 'You're prepared. You're fine. You know the game plan.' "He was the only person I'd told dur- ing the school day. But I said, 'I'm going to tell our offensive coaches that you're Michigan's Top Three Freshman QBs Michigan quarterbacks understand the bottom line, from Day 1. It's about winning. Style points don't matter. Given that measuring stick, here are the three most productive U-M quarterbacks in terms of winning games as a freshman. Chad Henne, 2004: Henne started all 12 Michigan football games in 2004 as a freshman. The Wolverines went 9-3 overall, 7-1 in the Big Ten, with Henne becoming the first freshman quarterback in the conference to ever lead his team to a league championship. Henne re- mains the only true freshman ever to do so in the Big Ten. Michigan also very nearly topped Texas that year in a wild Rose Bowl shootout. Henne threw for 227 yards and 4 touchdowns in that game but found himself barely out- run by the Longhorns' Vince Young, who rushed for 192 yards and 4 TDs while throwing for another 180 and 1 touchdown in Texas' 38-37 win. Bryce Underwood, 2025: Underwood became the youngest Michigan starting quarter- back ever last season. He directed the Wolverines to a 9-4 record, 7-2 in the Big Ten, good for fourth place. Underwood threw for 2,428 yards and 17 touchdowns and was expected to take the next step as a starter this season. A lack of overall offensive production triggered a midseason switch at QB to Tommy Carr. Rick Leach, 1975: Leach became the first true freshman in modern Michigan football history to take command as the starter. He started 11 of Michigan's 12 games, leading the Wolverines to an 8-2-2 record and a second-place finish in the Big Ten. Leach led Bo Schembechler's option attack, while throwing for 3 touchdowns versus 12 interceptions. — John Borton

